Cardiff
Cardiff.jpg

Break clauses – estoppel to the rescue

Break notices are often contested due to the significant consequences that they have for both landlords and tenants.

The established rule is that break clauses must be strictly complied with.

The case of Sterling House Ltd v International Baccalaureate Organisation (UK) Ltd [2025] EWHC 2680 (BP) gave the tenants a rare but important victory.

Background

The defendant tenant had a lease of premises known as Sterling House, Cardiff Gate Business Park. The lease was dated 23 February 2024.

It served a break notice to terminate its lease on 23 February 2026.

The break clause was conditional on all outstanding rent and insurance rent having been paid.

Prior to the break date, the tenant requested an invoice from the landlord’s managing agent to ensure that all the sums due under the lease were paid as at the break date. The agents issued an invoice but this only covered rent up to the break date. The tenant paid the invoice.

It should be noted that the lease required rent to be paid quarterly in advance.

The landlord claimed that the break was ineffective because around £45,000 in annual rent remained outstanding as at the break date, and a further £2,300 of insurance rent remained unpaid having been demanded shortly before the break date.

Decision in the High Court

The High Court dismissed the landord’s claim. It held that it could not rely on the outstanding sums to invalidate the break.

The High Court held that the managing agent’s invoice was a clear representation to the tenant as to the amount of annual rent payable. The Court found that it was reasonable for the tenant to rely on the invoice given that it had specifically requested the invoice to ensure that it complied with the break conditions. The landlord was estopped from relying on the outstanding rent for the remainder of the quarter.

The demand for insurance rent was delivered at 3pm on the Friday before the Monday break date. The Court found that either estoppel extended to that sum, or in the alternative the late delivery of the insurance invoice did not provide the tenant with enough time to arrange payment.

What this decision means for landlords and tenants

Whilst break clauses generally require strict compliance, this case demonstrates that in certain circumstances, landords may be prevented from relying on non-compliance if the tenant has been led to believe that the relevant conditions have been satisfied.

Landlords and their agents should ensure that any invoices provided ahead of the break date correctly reflect the lease provisions. They should ensure that tenants are provided with invoices a reasonable time ahead of the break date to give them sufficient time to make payment.

Tenants should be aware that this case does not alter the requirement to comply with the strict break clause conditions contained in their leases, but they may be able to run an estoppel argument if they have reasonably relied on representations made by the landlord or its agents.

Sterling House Ltd. v International Baccalaureate Organisation (UK) ltd [2025] EWHC 2680 (BP)